I like:
Ellis
Bryant (while it isn't my style at all, it's fashionable and very usable so I like it in that manner)
Pearl
Astor (I like, especially as I've been watching Dexter lately. I always mishear it as Esther though)
Park (I prefer Parker, but still nice!)
Sullivan
Mercer
I dislike:
Carroll
Houston (I might like if it were used on a boy, but even then...)
Delancey
Carnegie (I love the idea of it, it just sounds a little too rough for me.. and sounds like noogie, like ruffling someones head vigorously lol)
Vanderbilt
Amsterdam
Columbus (I want to like, has lots of nick name potential, but... don't want Christopher Columbus attached to my kiddo)
Nolita
Gramercy (nick name Gram? Or Grammar Nazi? lol)
Lorimer (maybe I could grow on it but seems too odd or me now)
Chelsea (not original and not my style)
Stuyvesant
Spring (I like the idea, I just can't see a Dr. Spring Smith. I can't see it aging)
Prince
And I'm on the fence with:
Waverly
Hudson
Lex
Brooklyn (would be on my "like" list except its not very original haha)
Perry
Wythe (for some reason not automatically disliking though I feel I should. Interesting!)
Fulton (nice, nms)
Bowery (I want to like it but when I say it out loud it comes out funny)
Clinton (it does make a nice name, I'm just afraid it sounds too political)
Varick (I think suits a boy more than girl. Not my style but could be nice on someones kid)
Carmine
So I pretty much dislike more than I like. I appreciate the variety though! I'm the same where I expect overused/ popular/ etc sorts of names on these articles. This one was a fun one even if I didn't like many haha.