Aaron or Adam
Abel or Amos
Abraham or Abram
Andrew or Asher (Close)
Benjamin or Boaz
Cain or Caleb (Close)
Christian or Cornelius
Daniel or David
Eli or Elias
Elijah or Elisha
Enoch or Ethan
Ezekiel or Ezra
Gabriel or Gideon (Close)
Ira or Israel
Isaac or Isaiah (Close)
Jacob or James
Jason or Jeremiah
Jesse or Jethro
Joel or Jonah
John or Jonathan
Joash or Joseph
Joshua or Josiah
Judah or Jude
Lazarus or Levi
Lot or Luke
Malachi or Matthew
Mark or Moses
Micah or Michael
Nathan or Nathaniel
Nicodemus or Noah
Obadiah or Othniel
Paul or Peter
Philip or Phineas
Reuben or Rufus
Samson or Samuel
Seth or Silas
Simeon or Simon
Solomon or Stephen
Thaddeus or Theophilus
Thomas or Timothy
Titus or Tobias
Uriah or Uzziah
Zacchaeus or Zechariah
Zebulun or Zedekiah
Adam or Abel
Abraham or Andrew
Benjamin or Caleb
Christian or David (Close)
Elias or Elijah (Close)
Ethan or Ezra
Gideon or Israel
Isaac or Jacob
Jeremiah or Jesse (Close)
Jonah or John
Joseph or Josiah
Jude or Levi
Luke or Matthew
Mark or Michael
Nathaniel or Noah (Close)
Obadiah or Peter
Phineas or Rufus (Close)
Samuel or Seth
Simon or Stephen
Thaddeus or Timothy
Tobias or Uriah
Zechariah or Zedekiah
Adam or Andrew
Benjamin or David (Close)
Elias or Ezra (Close)
Gideon or Jacob
Jeremiah or Jonah
Josiah or Levi
Matthew or Michael (Close)
Nathaniel or Peter (Close)
Phineas or Seth
Simon or Timothy
Tobias or Zedekiah
Andrew or Benjamin
Elias or Gideon
Jeremiah or Levi
Matthew or Peter
Phineas or Timothy or Tobias
(all of the above were close, I like all of them)
Andrew or Gideon
Jeremiah or Peter
Timothy or Tobias
(this is starting to get too hard)
Gideon or Peter
Peter or Tobias
(just cruel...)
Peter wins!