This has been done a few times, but I thought I'd create my own now
1. Move 2 names you don't like from Purgatory to Hell
2. Move 2 names you do like from Purgatory to Heaven
3. Move 1 name you do like from Hell to Purgatory
4. Move 1 name you don't like from Heaven to Purgatory
5. When all names have been placed in Heaven or Hell, we eliminate. Eliminate your favourite name from Hell and your least favourite from Heaven until we have one left in each.
Abigail, Adelaide, Alberta, Alexandra, Alice, Alina, Amelia, Ann, Barbara, Bernadine, Billie, Brooke, Carol, Charlotte, Constance, Darlene, Elaine, Elizabeth, Ellen, Emily, Emma, Faye, Gabrielle, Grace, Irene, Jean, Joan, Jocelyn, Julianne, Karla, Leah, Louise, Marion, Marjorie, Maude, Mavis, Miranda, Morgan, Natalie, Olivia, Rosemarie, Ruth, Sabrina, Sarah, Shirley