Baby Name Poll Results

Bookmark and Share

James Patrick vs. Seamus William

We have one son, James Patrick Truman - 2 and are pregnant with our second son. We really love the name Seamus, which is the Irish version of James. To us, the two names are completely different, but have a common meaning. We need to know what others think about have two sons, James and Seamus. Are they too similar???

The Top Baby Name is...

James Patrick Truman

63%

Seamus William Truman

38%

Poll created: Aug 01, 2009
Total Votes: 8

Comments

Personally, I wouldn’t do it. I would never be able to name one of my children Juan and the other John or Liam and William or Isabelle and Elizabeth.

Perhaps you’d like Eamon or Sean? Both share qualities and sounds with Seamus.
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report
I don’t feel they are too similar. Most people would not know that Seamus is the irish version of James. However, I would not used the name because your poor son would be teased about "semen" all his school life.
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report
i don’t think people know seamus is james, sheena is jane, susannah is lily, or kennedy is "ugly head" -- no one will notice but you and maybe a name geek.
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report
what about Shamus. that is a better name. seamus sounds dirty
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report
Your kids will know if they ever decide to see what their name means.
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report
I am not sure I am pronouncing Seamus right but if I am they don’t sound too similar!
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report
Come on you guys, it doesn’t rhyme with semen...Seamus is pronounced shaymus. I don’t think its a big deal that they are variations of the same name, they are still very different. They might think it’s cool to have the connection.
posted by guest :: 14 years ago | report

Post a Comment:

Please keep your comments positive and helpful.
Even if you don't like the names. Thanks!

 

Characters remaining: 0

You are not logged in. You are posting a comment as a guest.
» Login   » Register

Display Name:

For all baby name poll questions, complaints, or improvements
contact us.