Baby Name Poll Results

Lucy Tatum and Taryn Oakley
Lucy Anne and Teagan Rose
Lucy Makenna and Maren Oakley
Lucy Bronte and Tatum Olivia
Lucy Anne and Tatum Corinne
Lucy Anne and Tatum Carys

I agree Tatum Oakley sounds too masculine, especially with Lucy Anne.

If you picked Lucy Anne then let him pick Tatum Oakley. Be fair about it. If he loves Tatum Oakley then use it. You love Lucy Anne so he should get to use something he loves.

Lucy Anne & Tara Olivia

Lucy Camryn and Oakley Grace
Lucy Anne and Delaney​ Tatum
Lucy Anne and Erin Jade
Lucy Anne and Riley Marie
Lucy Morgan and Taten Ella

I'd change Lucy's middle name. Together it sounds like Luisanne ice tea, or almost like Louisiana.

Let him keep Tatum Oakley. It would be so unfair to me if you got to use Lucy Anne, the one you love, but you made him chnge the one he loves. If you get to use a name you love then let him use the name he loves. Lucy and Tatum are perfectly fine together. Both names don't have to be super frilly and girly. I have a friend with 2 year old twin boys named Avery and Nicholas, a lot of people told her that Avery was too girly next to Nicholas when she was pregnant but she gets compliments on how handsome both of her boys and their names are.

How about Lucy Tatum and Oakley Anne? This way, you both get to use names you love and a name you both love is in both of your daughters' names. Also, it makes Oakley's name less masculine (even thought Tatum was first a girl's name, and most people don't use it for a boy).

Those names do not go very well with each other. Not a fan of Tatum for a girl or a boy. Love the name Lucy.

Tatum Oakley is too masculine and trendy sounding, it doesn't go with Lucy at all. How about Avery or Harper?

I think Tatum Oakley is too masculine next to Lucy Anne. I also agree though that if you and your husband agreed to each name one baby, that you need to go through. However, I honestly think it would be a better idea to scrap both names and work together to find something you both like. Talk to each other about what you want in a name and then go to work trying to find that. Then your girls will have names you BOTH like and not names that one of you loves but the other one has a problem with.

Tatum is okay but Oakley is truly hideous, give her something clearly girly in the middle like Tatum Olive or Tatum Oriane

Love Tatum but not Oakley

No