Heaven
Aidan, Alexa, Alexandra, Alma, Amelia, Andrew, Annalise, Ava, Benjamin, Brennen, Caitlyn, Caleb, Cameron (M), Charles, Christian, Christopher, Clare, Colton, Cooper, Daniel, Dylan, Edmond, Elisabeth, Emily, Erica, Evan, Hayden, Hunter (M), Isabelle, James (M), Jonas, Jordan (M), Joshua, Lexie, Logan, Madeline, Madison, Michael, Nathaniel, Noah, Paige, Rachel, Samantha, Sam (M), Sarah, Shawn, Silas, Sydney (F), Tara, Tristan (M), William, Zachary, Zane
Hell
Anehel (F), Antonio, Austin, Blue (F), Brandon, Breanna, Brinley, Brennen, Brodey, Brystol (F), Cesar, Chrystal, Clayton, Cody, Corey, Courtney, Devin (F), Emilin, Garrett, Gibson, Gila, Harivansh (M), Heather, Jacki, Jamexo (M), Jaycee, Kacie (F), Kaylee, Keller (M), Kelsey, Koy, Kylee, Kyler, Kylie, Manuel, Marlee, Mason, Mayra, Presley, Rachael, Reagan (F), Shakira, Sierra, Sylvia, Ta'liyah, Trent, Trevor, Yareli, Whitney, Zack
Eliminated from Heaven: Savanna
Eliminated from Hell: Piper