Thanks so much for the feedback! I'll throw a few more names out here that I've been thinking about. Also, The 100 is a post-nuclear-apocalypse television show where a hundred teenage prisoners are sent to the ground to see if Earth is survivable. It's pretty good, so if it sounds interesting to you I'd check it out It's on Netflix but channel-wise it's on the CW.
Flint
This is a huge guilty pleasure name for me at the moment. It's significantly more unusual than the rest of the names on my list, but I just adore the name's meaning, how flint starts a little spark of fire. Also, it sounds similar to Finn, which is getting really popular, so maybe it's not too much of a stretch?
Whit
Another GP. It's a classic, much like Will, and also like Will I like just plain Whit and can't find any long name that I like it as a nickname for. But I think it might be too short to use on its own. Also, it's a nice nod to the word "wit."
Rhett
This is one I've been tossing around lately, also different from my usual style. It's got a sort of country feel that I like.
Ophelia
This one is causing me angst lately because it's too long not to have a nickname, and I can't decide on one. I'm not a fan of Ophie (like Sophie without an S). Phelie is cute to me but is pronounced "feely" which could be an issue. And there's Lia, which isn't too bad but I feel like it's not really related to the sound of Ophelia overall.
Thanks again in advance!