Heaven
Alexa, Alexandra, Andrew, Ava, Benjamin, Brennen, Caitlyn, Caleb, Charles, Christian, Christopher, Clare, Cooper, Daniel, Dylan, Edmond, Elisabeth, Emily, Evan, James (M), Joshua, Lexie, Madeline, Madison, Michael, Nathaniel, Noah, Paige, Rachel, Samantha, Sarah, Tristan (M), William, Zane
Hell
Blue (F), Brandon, Breanna, Brinley, Brystol (F), Cesar, Chrystal, Clayton, Corey, Courtney, Devin (F), Emilin, Gila, Harivansh (M), Heather, Jacki, Jamexo (M), Jaycee, (F), Keller (M), Kelsey, Kylee, Kyler, Kylie, Marlee, Presley, Reagan (F), Shakira, Trent, Trevor, Whitney
Eliminated from Heaven: Sam (M)
Eliminated from Hell: Sierra