Matthew Paige or Matthew David
Matthew Staton or Matthew Gray
Alexander Richard or Ian Michael
Justin Drew or Liam James
Thomas William or Thomas Cruise
Christopher Whitelaw or John Burke
Zachary David Alexander (I'm sorry, he's still hot) or David Robert Joseph
Scott Andrew or Denzel Hayes
Elisha Nelson or Aaron Charles
Bradley Charles or Jeremy Lee
Daniel Wroughton or Landon Timothy
Bradley Edwin or Timothy Matthew
Cody Robert or Paul Davis
Willard Mitt or Willard Christopher
Patrick Galen or James Todd
Logan Wade or Nils Allen
Taylor Daniel or Neil Leslie
Christopher Ashton or Seth Benjamin
Theodore Peter James or Thomas Edward Patrick
Troyal Garth or Brian Douglas
Shane Steven or John Joseph
Keegan Phillip or Stephen Robert
Paul Matthew Hawke or Andy Samuel
Jensen Ross or Adam Noah
Walter Bruce or Andrew Lloyd
Reginald Kenneth or Kenneth Arnold
Matthew David or Matthew Gray
Alexander Richard or Justin Drew
Thomas William or John Burke
David Robert Joseph or Scott Andrew
Aaron Charles or Bradley Charles
Landon Timothy or Timothy Matthew
Cody Robert or Willard Mitt
James Todd or Logan Wade
Taylor Daniel or Seth Benjamin
Theodore Peter James or Brian Douglas
John Joseph or Keegan Phillip
Andy Samuel or Adam Noah
Andrew Lloyd or Kenneth Arnold
Matthew David or Justin Drew
Thomas William or David Robert Joseph
Bradley Charles or Timothy Matthew
Cody Robert or Logan Wade
Seth Benjamin or Theodore Peter James
Keegan Phillip or Adam Noah or Andrew Lloyd
Matthew David or Thomas William
Timothy Matthew or Logan Wade
Seth Benjamin or Adam Noah or Andrew Lloyd
Matthew David or Logan Wade
Adam Noah or Andrew Lloyd
Logan Wade or Andrew Lloyd
Logan Wade (Lerman) wins!
Off the top of my head I recognized Efron, Levine, Bieber, Gubler, Webber (unless a celebrity other than him has that first/middle combo), Lerman, Lautner, Cooper, Ackles, Willis, Washington, Cruise
I'm guessing McConaughey is on here but I'm not entirely sure which one he is. I'm also guessing Payne is who I think it is. As well as Renner.