Well thats incredibly rude and disrespectful! Those are the same sorts of names on my list, so if they are disgusting, then I guess I've got a gross taste for names too I'd have reported her comment. Theres no need for that
Maude - I love it. Its a guilty pleasure for me as I don't see myself using it in real life, but I really like it.
Mabel - no doubt, 100% I know I'd use this name for my firstborn girl if my OH didn't have a say hehe <3 Mabel just kinda makes my heart melt I love it. Sassy, sweet, and just so adorable all in one. I am so in love with it <3
Beatrice - for whatever reason, I don't care for Beatrice. Nothing particular, guess I don't love the sound. But its not a bad name, just not one I'd use.
Evelyn - I like it, though I work for a store called "Crabtree & Evelyn" so my first thought is a botanists surname lol. But its a good name. I'd totally use its nick name, Evie, on a future daughter
Florence - its alright, I would like it on someone elses kiddo <3
Clara - adorable
Ada - I love it
Eleanor - beautiful, I'd totally use this too <3
Marilla - I don't love it, but its a fine name
Dorothy - another I don't particularly love, but its alright
Margaret - cuuute <3
Alice - I really like!
Augusta - not my cup of tea
Ethel - cute
Agnes - adorable
Edith - aw I love it. I'd totally use it in real life <3
Dorothea - same as Dorothy, just nms
Elsie - aw I love it! This ones in my top 5, definitely!
Henrietta - cuuuuuute
Iris - nms, but its nice
Ivy - I love Ivy so much!
Josephine - beautiful
Millicent - nice, I love nick name Millie
Minerva - Its one I'd adore on someone elses kiddo, though I'd not use on mine.
I think your list is beautiful! We have such similar styles <3