Thanks so much ladies!!
Hannah, Mike doesn't like Evie on its own <3 I'd probably end up calling her Eve consistently, but I do love Evie so much I couldn't help but use it <3 It is short, simple, and fussless though! <3 I actually kinda prefer Evie on its own, but Mike doesn't, so I'm okay with this compromise
Madi, I agree Everly is questionable with our surname
const3llati0ns, I do like a lot of forms of Eve, though a lot of them just don't go with the surname. Like Evangeline is just too long! And Evelyn reminds me of work too much to use it. I'm not a huge fan of many other forms, but thank you!!
Lauren, thats such a sweet association <3 I think it'd be lovely if you got to use it!

If I used Everly, I think I'd go with Everly Jade just because it honors and its nice and short <3 Eden is fairly place namey, and does have biblical associations for the garden and all.
ElizabethRuth, I do imagine Everly to go up in popularity, but I'm hoping there are others who are maybe turned off by how close it sounds to Beverly? But eh. I'll get to it first!! Lol jk. If I were due tomorrow that'd be one thing, but I still have five months haha. Sometimes celebrity names don't spike in popularity though, occasionally. Normally more odd ones though... oh well
Ah I am in love with how classic it is <3 and almost old fashioned yet not. Surprised me that Mike likes it! <3 I guess in this day and age and especially with all the Eva's and Evelyn's currently out there the association slowly fades. Wow thanks for the suggestions! <3 I like Eve Cadence, Eve Charlotte, Eve Madelyn, Eve Caroline, Eve Celeste, Eve Scarlett, and Eve Gwendolyn <3 I just have to see what Mike likes of those now
Alyssa, Ever is pretty as well, though I'm unsure just yet how much I like it <3 Like Everly, it may need time to grow on me

Its unfortunately true though, celebs use beautiful names all the name and even though it normally does effect popularity at least to an extent, I don't want to let it rule out the potentially perfect name for my bubba
Thank everyone and their opinions so much!! They really helped!